Drawing from the fact that, I am a social anarchist, socialism tends to come into it, and while at the utmost I consider to be an anarchist, I wish to broaden my mind and to be able to understand the basics of socialism, anarchism, communism and all the other left wing theories. To be able to understand, why perhaps I'm not an advocate for their cause and so far concerning socialism I think I've found quite a few points that have ingrained into me that I am most definitely not a socialist!
A flaw I have found within the party was that keeps on coming back to me, is their definition of working class. They would define the working class using Marx's term as one of who has only but their labour to sell, however they would consider even those who many would believe to be middle class as working class if they have but their labour to sell, making a figure of about 80% of the population. Broadly speaking, I think this is an incorrect definition of the working class, myself coming from a pretty working class family in its roots and both household income today, I actually find it rather offensive, having known plenty of people who can afford a much better lifestyle and more possessions than I, have not had to know the hardships of not being able to afford school books and buying them for about 1p of Amazon. The class struggle is not over, with their now being described as what is known as an underclass... This means to me only that the gap between the rich and the poor is now actually widening. While in theory, you may be able to say even those of the middle class are also working class, I believe it to be a huge understatement and shows a lack of understanding to what working class means. Working class is a whole different attitude to the middle class. Just as the skinheads and punks held different attitudes... so do the working and middle classes.
I think the central point about this issue is that class and class-consciousness doesn't depend centrally on your absolute wealth level or living standard. The European and American working class live considerably better than those in Egypt, for example. But that doesn't mean that our struggle is not their struggle, because we share a common interest in the abolition of capitalism. Our lives and the lives of egyptian workers are fucked up and stunted by the capitalist class - yes, to carying degrees of intensity, but the enemy is the same and the fundamental feature of class struggle for a better world is the same. That forms the basis of solidarity.
ReplyDeleteI'm an SWP member, but I wish you luck finding the best group for you on the left, whether it's us or ALARM or whoever. x